He Threatened His Surrogate With a Lawsuit and Told Her to Reimburse Him if She Insisted on Keeping His Baby. Now He’s Called a “Cruel, Unreasonable Jerk!” Was He Wrong?

A man and his husband wanted to have a kid, so they chose surrogacy. Everything was fine until eight months in when the surrogate and biological mother decided she wanted to keep the baby!

Troubling Scenario

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Tarasenko16Dima

OP (Original Poster) is a 33-year-old man who found himself in a “difficult situation” with his 25-year-old surrogate, Maria.

For some context, OP explained that he and his 37-year-old husband, Roman, decided to go with surrogacy to have a child. He said, “We had a legal agreement in place, and Maria was compensated generously for her part in carrying our baby.”

Confused Minds

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Ground Picture

Everything was going smoothly, and the couple was excited about the arrival of their child. However, after eight months of Maria carrying their baby, she dropped a huge bomb on OP and Roman.

OP wrote, “She declared that she no longer wanted to go through with the surrogacy and expressed her desire to keep the child.”

A Serious Question

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Khosro

OP said that his husband, Roman, flew into a rage when he heard what Maria said. OP calmed him down and removed him from the situation so he and Maria could have a one-on-one conversation.

Legal Benchmarks

Image Credit: Shutterstock / fizkes

OP reminded her that she had signed the contract and that the child was, without any question, their baby, not hers.

In California, traditional surrogacy is allowed. Since the three parties involved had a pre-birth agreement, this meant that OP and his husband would have to give up their rights to the child before Maria could keep the baby, which they weren’t going to do.

A Heartfelt Plea

Image Credit: Shutterstock / BearFotos

Maria pleaded with OP, but he stood his ground, asserting that the child she was carrying was his baby. Then, she tried to bargain, saying she no longer wanted the money—only the baby.

No Way

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

OP was firm in his rejection of her request, and he reminded her that no one had coerced her into signing the papers that made the child legally theirs, whether she liked it or not.

Money Talks

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Srdjan Randjelovic

To add more weight to the situation, OP reminded Maria that they had already paid her a lot of money and invested a lot in the baby. If she wanted out of the contract, she would have to reimburse them, which was something she wasn’t in a position to do, and OP knew it.

Driving the Point Home

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Mix and Match Studio

OP then suggested that Maria talk to their lawyers if she had any concerns or questions. As far as OP and his husband were concerned, they had settled the matter, and the child was theirs, no matter how she felt about the situation.

A Heartless Couple

Image Credit: Shutterstock / ShotPrime Studio

After the conversation, Maria called OP and his husband “cruel” and even involved her family in supporting her case. Roman supported OP and his stance on the matter, but some of their friends said they were “a**holes,” so OP wanted to know what Reddit thought.

A Legal Point

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

Maria currently has not pursued legal action at all.

He said, “The baby is mine and my husband’s. There hasn’t been a pursuit of legal action; she can now only talk through my lawyers.”

Redditors’ Two Cents

Image Credit: Shutterstock / oasisamuel

As you can imagine, this situation split the community quite a bit. A lot of Redditors were very uncomfortable with the concept of traditional surrogacy, where the biological mom was also the surrogate.

One comment was, “Unfortunately, this is why doctors will not allow the egg donor and surrogate to be the same person. Who advised you to proceed in this manner? Due to her being the biological mother, your contract is potentially void. I would consider consulting with a family law attorney so your husband can plan to file for custody. In the future, if you decide to have more children, go with a surrogacy agency and separate egg donor so you can avoid this issue. OP is a man and commented that the surrogate is also the egg donor. i.e., the surrogate is the biological mother. OP has no physical relationship with the baby. His husband’s sperm fertilized the surrogate’s egg.”

Complex Scenario

Image Credit: Shutterstock / nakaridore

Another Redditor focused on how complicated OP’s situation is.

This user said, “People can downvote me all they want, but the facts remain: traditional surrogacy is much more legally complex than gestational surrogacy because the surrogate is the biological mother of the child. For both intended parents to have parental rights for the child, the non-biological intended parent will likely need to complete a stepparent adoption following the baby’s birth.”

A Sad Situation

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Cookie Studio

A lot of the community was saddened by the situation, with many calling out how wrong traditional surrogacy was.

One comment about traditional surrogacy hit home for a lot of posters, saying, “To be honest, I think this goes beyond the scope of am I the a**hole. It was a huge mistake to use a surrogate and use her egg. She is giving you her child. I’m glad you have papers, but dang, a legit agency set this up? I kinda want to say everybody sucks here, as in everything is sad here.”

It’s Her Child, Too

Image Credit: Shutterstock / ViDI Studio

Then, others pointed out that no matter what contract or agreement OP and Roman claim they have, nothing will ever trump the fact that Maria’s the biological mom of the child.

One woman said, “She can sign whatever they want, but if it’s her egg and she’s carrying it, then she can absolutely claim partial custody. Not saying it’s right or wrong; just pointing out why it’s a terrible idea to have the bio mom carry the baby. It’s basically an adoption agreement.”

What do you think about OP and Maria’s situation? Is traditional surrogacy a bad idea, or should it be allowed in more states?

More From Quote Ambition

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

This Redditor turned to the community for advice after being called out for being a horrible woman for not wanting to raise a baby born from her ex-husband’s affair. Was she wrong to refuse?

She Refused to Raise an Affair Baby After Her Ex-husband and Wife Died. Now Her Former Mother-In-Law Calls a “Horrible, Evil Woman!”

An Entitled Woman Refused to Vacate His Assigned Seat on a Five-Hour Flight. So, He Kicked and Yanked the Chair Every Two Minutes, Ensuring There’s “Extra Turbulence” All Flight Long!

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

He got annoyed when a woman wouldn’t budge and get off his assigned plane seat, saying she was “already comfortable.” So, he devised a plan to make sure she’d regret every second of it!

An Entitled Woman Refused to Vacate His Assigned Seat on a Five-Hour Flight. So, He Kicked and Yanked the Chair Every Two Minutes, Ensuring There’s “Extra Turbulence” All Flight Long!

She Left Her Cousin’s Wedding and Took Her $1,000 Gift Back After the Groom’s Family Ruined Her Dress for Being “Inappropriate.” They Want the Money Back, but It’s Too Late

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

OP (Original Poster) was stoked to attend her favorite cousin’s wedding. However, little did she know it would become one of the worst experiences of her life yet!

She Left Her Cousin’s Wedding and Took Her $1,000 Gift Back After the Groom’s Family Ruined Her Dress for Being “Inappropriate.” They Want the Money Back, but It’s Too Late

A Woman Noticed Their Security Cameras Glitched Only When Her Husband Was Home Alone. He Flipped Out After Being Confronted, but She Wants to Get to the Bottom of Things!

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Krakenimages.com

This Redditor’s home security cameras kept on glitching whenever her husband was home alone. Suspicious of what was causing this, she asked her husband, but instead of remaining calm, he got defensive!

A Woman Noticed Their Security Cameras Glitched Only When Her Husband Was Home Alone. He Flipped Out After Being Confronted, but She Wants to Get to the Bottom of Things!

He Begged His Neighbors to Extinguish Their Fire So His Dying Dog Could Spend One Last Day Outdoors, but They Showed No Sympathy. So, He Ensured They Learned Their Lesson!

Image Credit: Shutterstock / Shift Drive

He only wanted to give his dog a day in his backyard before putting her down. However, things didn’t go as planned when his neighbors decided to light a fire so close to them!

He Begged His Neighbors to Extinguish Their Fire So His Dying Dog Could Spend One Last Day Outdoors, but They Showed No Sympathy. So, He Ensured They Learned Their Lesson!

This post first appeared as He Threatened His Surrogate With a Lawsuit and Told Her to Reimburse Him if She Insisted on Keeping His Baby. Now He’s Called a “Cruel, Unreasonable Jerk!” Was He Wrong? on Quote Ambition.

Read Next:

Karen Danao

Hi, I’m Karen, a content curator and writer for Quote Ambition; I’m also a marketing and advertising professional. Beyond the keyboard and the screen, I’m someone who’s out to enjoy every bit that life has to offer!

Poetry, philosophy, history, and movies are all topics I love writing about! However, my true passion is in traveling, photography, and finding common ground to which everyone from different cultures can relate.

With the many places I’ve been to, I found that love, inspiration, and happiness are some things that bring people together. No matter how different we are on the outside, I’m a true believer that our emotions don’t lie; if you dig deep into our psyche, we’re all the same inside.

This belief was further amplified when I joined Quote Ambition. Through the quotes I’ve read, collected, organized, and written about, I found that humans are resilient, creative, and compassionate.

We take from each others’ hearts and courage, and it’s through our individual experiences that we learn how to rise above our challenges and pain. In so many ways, Quote Ambition is a platform that allows people from all over the world to gain the inspiration they need anytime, anywhere!